Dating Violence in Youth Relationships

Dating Violence in Youth Relationships

What is it? And How Do We Prevent It?

by Rona Amiri, BWSS Violence Prevention Co-ordinator

What is youth dating violence?

Dating violence is defined as a systematic pattern of domination where one partner uses abusive tactics to maintain power and control over the other partner and where these tactics escalate over time and where the victim alters her behaviour in an attempt to stop the abuse.  (Battered Women’s Support Services 1993) Basically meaning your partner is trying to control you and using different abusive tactics to maintain that control.

So why is this relevant?

Youth between the ages of 15 and 24, in Canada, have the highest risk of dating violence. Police-reported statistics show us the number of dating violence survivors is highest among the 15-24 age group representing 43% of all incidents of dating violence in Canada. That’s pretty high and means as youth we experience a lot of dating violence. We also know young women between the ages of 15-19 experience ten times more violence in relationships than young men. So while dating violence is also experienced by young men the number of young women who experience dating violence is disproportionately greater.

In terms of same-sex relationships we see that males accounted for 60% of these incidents, and females accounted for 40%. Thus, in general, boys and men perpetrate more violence in dating relationships whether they are same-sex or different-sex. Yes, this is a gender related issue. There is clearly something happening in male culture that makes this violence acceptable.

What does dating violence look like?

Here are some tactics used by perpetrators of dating violence to maintain power and control within the relationship:

Physical

Physical violence is probably what most of us think of when we hear the term dating violence. 1 in 3 youth know a friend who has experience physical violence in a dating relationship. Most of us think that it’s probably easy to spot and stop physical violence. However, it can be more complicated that we think. There are the obvious types of physical violence which come to mind immediately: kicking, punching, scratching, biting, strangling. But then there are the less obvious methods of physical violence like pushing you against a locker in the hallway, grabbing your arm so you can’t leave, using their body to physically block an exit, and smacking your butt without consent. Our peers are less likely to interfere when a situation looks like a private matter or doesn’t look overtly violent.

Sexual

Being young and female is a risk factor of sexual assault. 86% of sexual offences reported to the police in the year 2004 were committed against females. Manipulating and making threats to get sex falls under this category as well. It doesn’t necessarily need to be overtly forceful to be considered sexual violence. For example, saying “if you loved me you would have sex with me” is a manipulative way to pressure someone into sex.

Emotional

Okay so we all know physical violence is not okay and most of us think if things got to that level we would leave. But what happens if there is no physical violence? No all abusive relationships include physical violence. It is important that we are able to recognize emotional abuse because it is the most common type of violence used. Dating violence is about maintaining power and control over ones partner.

Some behaviours that fall under emotional abuse category include threats, name calling, humiliation, intimidation, threats, and isolation. Constantly calling/texting you and wanting to know where you are at all times is also emotional abuse. Threatening self harm is also used as a manipulative tactic to control your behaviours.

Digital

Power and control tactics used in dating violence are used in the world of social media as well. Perpetrators can harass their current or ex partners online with little to no consequences. This includes threatening to share intimate images or text messages. And for youth who may be LGBTQ*2S there may be threats to “out” them to their family/community. Because it is through social media these things can be possible over long periods of time or even if the people involved are far in terms of geography.

Another current issue is the use of “revenge porn” websites, which allow users to post naked photos or videos of ex-partners and even personal information online. We also know this to be a gendered issue because disproportionally the targets are young women.

How can I help my friend?

Here are some ways you can support a friend/classmate/family member who may be experiencing dating violence:

  • First of all, don’t be afraid to talk to someone if you think they need help! Let them know you notice what’s going on, that you want to help and make sure they are safe.
  • Don’t be judgemental! Listen patiently and be supportive, acknowledging their feelings. It’s also super important you do not tell your friend what to do, it’s important your feels empowered to make their own choices.
  • Remind your friend she is not alone and she deserves to be in a healthy relationship.
  • Focus on your friend and not the person who perpetrates the violence, it’s important she still feels she can trust you and talk to you even if chooses to stay in the relationship.
  • Tell your friend about BWSS resources, remember we can help!
  • Help your friend with a safety plan!

What is a safety plan?

As a friend you can help someone who is experiencing dating violence by make a safety plan! A safety plan is a set of actions that can help lower your friends’ risk of being hurt by their partner. It includes information specific to her life that will increase her safety at school, home, and other places she may go daily.

Here is a copy of BWSS’s safety plan online.

Next steps…

Conversations about dating violence in schools are uncommon and for most youth there are little to no spaces to have these discussions. What happens instead is gender violence is lumped in with discussions around bullying. While discussing bullying is important it’s also critical that we do not equate the two issues. In general, the terms bullying/cyber bullying are usually “depoliticized” versions for terms like sexism, gender violence, racism, homophobia, and/or transphobia. If dating violence or gender violence is misnamed then we can’t have real solutions to the problem.

Being able to identify dating violence when we see it is important but, nothing will change if we aren’t given tools to make changes happen. The best way to end dating violence is to work with our peers so they feel empowered to stand up against sexism and abuse they witness. This means we are supporting one another both in person but also online and on social media. If one of your peers is being harassed online it is important that we are speaking up against it and that we are not sharing any individuals’ information/photos without their consent.

Be critical of the media you consume! Mass media definitely normalizes abusive and sexist behaviours (mass media being TV, movies and music videos to name a few). That’s why we need to stay critical of the media we consume. Being media literate allows us to point out the sexism that is fed to us on a daily basis.

Stay connected with us through our social media platforms and share your thoughts on dating violence, media and social change!facebook_circle_color-512 Circle_TwitterBird

Learn more about our YOUth Ending Violence Program here.

If you could do something to end violence against girls and women, wouldn’t you?

images

YOUth Ending Violence ~ Education Presentation Opportunity 2014

Battered Women’s Support Services Education Presentation Opportunity

For 20 years Battered Women’s Support Services has delivered dating violence prevention education.

YOUth Engagement in Dating Violence Prevention.
Co-facilitated by a trained young woman and a young man.
YOUth Ending Violence: YOUth Engagement in Dating Violence Prevention

Anticipated outcomes:
• A better understanding of the roots of dating violence
• Types of abuse
• Healthy Relationships
• How to help a friend who is being abused
• Effective bystander intervention
• Safety Planning
• Media Literacy Skills
• Understanding Social Media
The length of the workshop is approximately 50 minutes. Two and four hour workshops are available upon request.
Book as soon as possible as our calendar fills up very quickly.

All the workshops are free.

By providing relevant education to youth about violence in dating relationships we are helping to end violence.
For information call Rona at 604.318.2011or email yev@bwss.org.

BWSS-Youth-Engagment-MAR-102-2014You can download the poster here.

Learn more about our YOUth Ending Violence Program here.

If you could do something to end violence against girls and women, wouldn’t you?

images

Youth Engagement in Dating Violence Prevention 2014

Youth Engagement in Dating Violence Prevention 2014

BWSS offers training for young women and men who want to volunteer for our YOUth Ending Violence Program to facilitate workshops for youth. To provide youth with knowledge on the difference between healthy and abusive relationships, discuss the role of the media in gender violence; and to support youth to feel empowered to speak out against dating violence and sexism.

Join Battered Women’s Support Services, facilitate dating violence prevention workshops for youth.

Participants will learn: • Feminist Framework of Gender Violence • Group Facilitation Skills • Presentation Skills • Leadership Skills • Empowered Bystander Intervention • Media Literacy

Training Sessions: March 15-16 and 22-23

To register or for more information call RONA at 604.318.2011 or email yev@bwss.org

BWSS Youth EV Volunteer POSTER 2014-page-001You can download the poster here.

Learn more about our YOUth Ending Violence Program here.

Last year, Battered Women’s Support Services responded to over 10,000 crisis calls from women and girls to get help and end violence. We could not provide this essential support without your contribution. images

YOUth Using Their Voice to End Dating Violence

yev

by Rona Amiri, BWSS YOUth Ending Violence Consultant

So far, 2013 has been an incredible year for violence prevention! We have facilitated workshops to over 1,400 youth throughout the Greater Vancouver area. We have facilitated workshops in Vancouver, Burnaby, Langley, Coquitlam, Port Coquitlam, Richmond, and Surrey. We have reached hundreds of youth from both high schools and community organizations. We have facilitated workshops for Indigenous youth groups and Newcomer/Immigrant youth groups.  This has been possible thanks to some amazing young women and men who volunteer as facilitators and are passionate about ending dating violence!

Early this year we trained a new group of youth facilitators. Our Executive Director, Angela Marie MacDougall, facilitated training with support from youth consultants, Rona Amiri and Tijash Ramirez. During the 5 days of training the new volunteers expanded their knowledge of gender violence and looked specifically at youth dating violence. They also gained presentation, facilitation, and leadership skills.

 Fotor090412290

Youth facilitators during 2013 training

 yev

Tijash, Isaac, and Khisrow during training

Youth have responded incredibly intelligently and thoughtfully when discussing gender violence. When presented with the facts they become more engaged and want to learn more about what they can do to make a difference.

Not all youth agree with everything we say during the workshop; however, they are respectful in their inquiries and challenges. It is great when youth ask questions or are critical of the information we provide because at least they are being honest. That honesty opens up the space for youth to really talk about dating violence in ways they never had the opportunity. Our facilitators provide the information, facts, and statistics around dating violence and help create a safe space for youth to discuss the issue.

A common misconception is that youth who are part of alternative school programs are ‘bad’ and don’t care about issues of violence and create a lot of violence. However, through our workshops we have seen youth in alternative programs be just as thoughtful if not more. Many of them understand the cycles of violence because of lived experiences and are just as passionate, if not more, about ending violence. We have had some amazing conversations with youth from alternative programs at North Surrey Secondary and Whyte Cliff Agile learning center in Burnaby.

We have also had the opportunity to facilitate workshops for young women who are part of after school groups or in community youth groups. These young women in the workshops were critical of a culture that continuously puts the responsibility on girls and women to ensure their safety instead of teaching boys and men to be respectful of girls and women. They thanked us for creating a safe space to discuss these issues that they have thought of before but never really spoke about. It is unbelievably humbling to be thanked for facilitating a workshop especially when we feel just as thankful to them for sharing their thoughts and being able to learn from them.

One thing that set apart our workshops is the focus we have on ending the violence. While we do share information about dating violence, our main goal is to support youth in feeling empowered to stand up against sexist and abusive behaviors. We discuss how we can support our peers who may be experiencing dating violence, how we can stop street harassment, and how we can be empowered bystanders to interrupt violence when we see it happening.

Here are a few quotes from youth in workshops as well as from our evaluations:

“The presentation will help reduce/prevent abuse when I am in a relationship to know my rights as a woman”

“I would be able to know what to do if my friends or myself encounter this situation”

“The presentation made me feel that it is my right to stand up for myself if something is wrong in my relationship”

“It gave me a lot of info on how to be a good boyfriend”

“Manhood is not all about being strong and tough”

“What I learned from the presentation is that there is more to abuse than physical violence”

“Presentation was good and provided a lot of examples to help us better understand dating violence”

“Really great presentation, I liked the videos”

“I learned about alcohol and consent”

“I learned how to be an empowered bystander:  thank you!!”

We have seen youth own their role in ending violence because they now have the tools to be empowered to stop and intervene when witnessing abusive or sexist behaviour and they have resources to support their peers who may be in a violent dating relationship.

For more information on YOUth Ending Violence prevention workshops email yev@bwss.org and/or visit here.

20 Ways Youth Can Prevent Violence Against Girls & Women

1. Use Social Media-Social media has an empowering effect send articles, with the click of a button, you can spread the word. Youth do not need the mainstream media to voice their views!

2. Report– Report photos that exploit girls and young women when you see them on social media sites like Facebook and Instagram

3. Be media literate and critical-Be critical of what you see otherwise it become normalized and we are desensitized! The media regularly uses images of violence against women and objectifies girls and women to sell products. Women are also objectified in movies, music and magazines. If you see an ad or commercial that is sexist and degrading towards women – write or e-mail the company and don’t by their products.

4. Interrupt sexist/homophobic and transphobic language-Words are powerful, especially when spoken by people who have power over others. We live in a society where words are used to put girls and women down. Gendered name-calling is used and sends the message, that, girls and women are less than fully human. When girls and women are seen as inferior, thus, it becomes easier to treat them with less respect and ignore their rights. Changing the way you speak can change the way you think.

5. Interrupt abuse –If you see a guy push a girl into her locker at school that you say something to stop him from continuing to be abusive. If you are at a party and one of your peers or friends is intoxicated and being lead away by a guy[s] stop him from being alone with her and help her get home.

6. Stop street harassment-Don’t engage in any forms of sexual harassment, such as catcalling, and unwanted touching. And don’t let your friends and peers engage in those behaviors either! It’s not just enough that you don’t engage in those behaviors, be empowered to speak up against friends and peers who do! Don’t look the other way!

7. Come up with an action plan– Plan ahead what you would do in situations where either, people you know or strangers, are being abusive and/or sexist. Sometimes it’s easier to interrupt and stop the abuse when you know what you will say and how you will approach the situation before hand.

8. Recognize the role of gender in violence- While boys and men do experience abuse it is important to remember that the majority of victims of abuse are female and the majority of perpetrators of violence are boys and men.

9. Stop Victim Blaming– Don’t blame girls and women for how they choose to dress or judge their behavior. Violence can’t be prevented through limiting the freedoms of girls. This only allows the violence to continue because perpetrators become invisible, and those who witness remain silent.

10. Stop rape culture– One way to stop rape culture is by not allowing people to perpetuate rape culture through minimizing/normalizing rape through jokes. When a friend or peer tells a joke about being violent against girls and women in some way, say you don’t find it funny and let them know that it is not okay.

11. Call gender violence what it is-not bullying-Using the term bullying to label violence against girls and women masks the truth of what’s happening. When someone you know at schools is experiencing gender violence either in a dating relationship or from their peers at school, by labeling it correctly you are stopping a culture, which normalizes and minimizes violence against girls and women.

12. Educate yourself on the roots of violence-Violence against girls and women stems in male dominance and the socialization of men. Become educated on the roots of violence against girls and women! Read books and articles, join a group at school and attend any training available to you.  Learn about the myths and realities of gender violence and understand how our society condones it.

13. Create safe spaces to discuss gender violence– Create an after school club or group where you can openly discuss your views and experiences and support your peers.

14. Confront yourself/your ideas-Reflect on your beliefs and why you have those beliefs and your actions, and opinions. Be honest and admit your faults and commit to changing the way you think and act.

15. Stop stereotyping men’s and women’s roles-Social roles and expectations may affect a man’s decisions about relationships. Men are taught that expressing feelings is not masculine. Examining your social role and learning ways to express feelings directly and non-violently can help to create deeper and more meaningful interpersonal relationships. You don’t have to prove yourself.

16. Remember violence is a choice- Don’t make excuses for friends and peers who are violent. Stop supporting the notion that violence is due to mental illness, lack of anger management skills, alcohol and drug use, stress, etc.

17. Be Supportive-When girls tell you about violence they have experienced in their lives believe them. It is extremely rare for girls to make up a story about rape or abuse. You may be the first and only person she tells. Believe her and support her decisions, without being judgmental.

18. Be aware of resources for girls and women-Support girls and women by providing information on where they can get further support and safety. Familiarize yourself with the resources for girls and women in your community, including women’s centers, counseling centers and health service organizations. Be a positive resource for girls close to you by sharing information and making referrals.

19. Talk to others about ending violence and be a mentor– Volunteer your time to preventing violence by speaking to others. This brings awareness to the issue, which will motivate others to act.

20. Understand consent- Boys and young men need to be respectful when entering into a sexual relationship and should not feel entitled to girls and women’s bodies. Just because you are a ‘nice guy’ does not mean you should have any expectations.

Remember gender violence is not an individual issue- We all have a role in ending violence against girls and women and it is important that we all take responsibility in ending the violence.

During Prevention of Violence Against Women Week we will engage our online community in violence prevention by remembering we all have a role to play in preventing violence against girls and women as individuals, in our relationships, in our community and in society.

For more information about “It’s in Your Hands”, please visit:

Preventing Violence Against Women – It’s In Your hands

Gender Violence in the Workplace

 

Lessons from Steubenville by Rona Amiri

 

Much has been said and written about the two young men, Trent Mays, 17 and Ma’lik Richmond, 16, who sexually assaulted a young woman in Steubenville, Ohio. The majority of sexual assault cases do not receive attention in the way that the Steubenville case has in the media. There are many lessons to learn from this highly publicized case including the role of bystanders, social media, sports culture, convictions and the response from mainstream media.

Role of Bystanders

Bystanders had a large role in this case, as they do in many cases of sexual assault. One of the bystanders, Evan Westlake, was the designated driver night; he realized his friends were too drunk to drive so he tricked them into handing over their car keys. However, Westlake did not intervene in the same way when he saw his friends sexually assaulting the young woman who was unconscious. Westlake had the opportunity to prevent his friends from sexually assaulting Jane Doe by firstly interrupting and stopping the sexual assault that was happening in the backseat of his car and secondly refusing to let the young men take her to another house.

Westlake said about the rape: “It wasn’t violent, I always pictured it as forcing yourself on someone.” For this reason, discussion about Westlake’s lack of intervention has been around the need for education around consent. And while discussions and education about consent are incredibly important and valuable there has been little to no discussion about the role of male sexual entitlement in all of this.

Male Sexual Entitlement and Consent

There is a culture of sexual entitlement for boys and men, which is the belief that “men are owed sex on account of their maleness”. This revolves around the notion that girls and women’s bodies are objects, which exist for male pleasure.

In this case for Westlake it was not a question of whether or not the boys had consent. It is highly probable Westlake and the perpetrators understand consent. Westlake probably didn’t say anything because he like others believed the young men were entitled to Jane Doe’s body due to male entitlement.  Differing from how it is currently being presented as Westlake not understanding consent. They knew what happened that night was rape because they discussed what they had done in a video where they repeatedly called what they had done that night rape. Furthermore, in messages on social media the young men said “the dead girl” was “so raped.” Which illustrates they knew what they had done was rape.  It appears that it is not about not understanding the meaning of consent, but rather, not caring about having consent or not.

Role of Social Media

Social media is involved in many cases of gender violence especially for youth who use social media as a means of communicating with one another on a daily basis.  Not only were there witnesses to the sexual assault but also other youth were aware of what happened through text messages and twitter postings. Social media has become a new medium for gender violence. The young woman’s humiliation quickly went viral. In this case, much has been said about how social media helped solve this crime. Texts messages, you tube videos, photographs on Instagram and posts on Twitter and Facebook were all used by the police to document what happened that night in Steubenville.

In this case, much has been said about how social media helped solve this crime. The judge advised those who witnessed the assault “to have discussions about how you talk to your friends, how you record things on the social media.” The reaction to the use of social media in cases like these should not be about not recording or taking photos of crimes, instead it should be how to use social media to prevent and stop violence against girls and women as it is happening.

Sports Culture & Masculinity

The sport of football is a hyper-masculine and physically aggressive sport that contributes to maintaining stereotypical notions of what it means to be a man (ie, tough, strong, physical, a leader). Football in Steubenville is highly regarded and the town’s sense of pride is connected to their high school football team and its players, which most likely attributed to the young men having power within the community.

Where were the male adult role models for these young men in all of this? A large part of the issue is the lack of positive male role models for boys and young men. One of the perpetrators biological father addressed the court and the victim’s family, placing some of the blame for his son’s actions on himself for being an absentee father.

However, it seems that regardless of the young man’s father not being around the boys had many adult male role models in the form of coaches on their football team. There is evidence that the football coach, Reno Saccoccia, was aware they raped the young woman and even tried to protect them from persecution. Text messages indicate the coach led the young men to believe the rape wasn’t a big deal at first: “Like, he was joking about it, so I’m not worried.”  There is also evidence that one of the perpetrators sent his coach a text message saying he ‘took care of ’ the rape allegations. Thus, it is clear their coach was aware of what was going on and by trying to help them from getting in trouble he only validated their idea that they did not do anything wrong.

Victim Blaming, Apologists & Media Response

As with most cases of sexual assault this young woman experienced a great deal of victim blaming. People are quick to judge and analyze decisions and so called ‘mistakes’ of young women who are sexually assaulted, instead of the actions of the perpetrators. In this case the young woman has been criticized for drinking too much, for agreeing to hang out with the boys and for “ruining” the lives of her rapists.

There has been little to discussion around this young woman thinking she may have been drugged while out that night. Almost immediately after arriving at the party that night a “date rape” drug was put into her drink because she has no memories of what happened that night after being picked up.  The young women thought she was aware of everything she drank that night, and had never blacked out before.

There are a lot of judgments of Jane Done and her decisions. Girls and women are expected to constantly be on guard to protect themselves from attackers however there is little to no discussion telling boys and men not to drug women and rape women. This steams from the large emphasis that is put on the actions of girls and women as if our choices make us guilty for being sexually assaulted. The conversation needs to move away from why wasn’t she more careful with her drinking and instead look at why young men are drugging and sexually assaulting young women at parties. The response from the public and the mainstream media reveals to us a culture where the person who is raped is the guilty one for allowing it to happen instead of the individual[s] who commit the crime.

Following the guilty verdict the young woman in Steubenville experience an onslaught of death threats through social media. Two teenage girls have been arrested for allegedly threatening the young woman following the verdict. Not only did this young woman experience gender violence by the young men who assaulted her, she was further harassed and threatened by her peers who blamed her for ruining the lives of the young men who raped her.

She knew the young men who betrayed her trust and sexually assaulted her. She went to the party that night because she liked and trusted those young men. There are many cases, just like this one, where young women are sexually assaulted and raped by boys and men they know.  Those young men told her that they were taking care of her while she was drunk. Yet, the public believes rape, is perpetrated by criminals in the ‘shadows’ who are strangers.

The young woman was blamed for ruining the lives of the perpetrators and the mainstream media’s response to the conviction was atrocious. For example, following the verdict a reporter from CNN talked about the young men as if they were somehow victims in all this: “these two young men that had such promising futures, star football players, very good students, literally watched as, as they believed their life fell apart”. The media reports (especially from CNN) were so ridiculous they were, unfortunately, almost comical and very similar to this Onion News parody from 2011.

Conviction

The young men received the minimum sentence for their convicted crimes, with the possibility of remaining in juvenile detention until age 21. The judge set the minimum sentence of one year for Richmond and Mays was sentenced to an additional year for distributing nude images of a minor. Mays and Richmond will be added to the juvenile sexual-offenders registry as well.

It’s important to note that the Steubenville conviction was an exception and not the norm.  Even a friend of the young male offenders said the boys would not be convicted if the case would be taken to court.  This is because many boys and men know that there are very few, if any consequences when it comes to violence against girls and women. It is highly probable that without all of the media attention on this case there would not have been a conviction.

Sexual assault and rape in many instances are underreported and in the few cases where they are reported very few result in convictions. Specifically, in Canada we know only 9% of sexual assaults are reported, only 33% of those result in charges, and only 11% of those result in convictions. (http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/85f0033m/85f0033m2008019-eng.pdf)

Although this specific case has now ended, it is important to continue the dialogue around consent, male sexual entitlement and the role of social media in gender violence. We invite you to join our conversations on how we can be effective bystanders, when it comes to youth and gender violence, on our Face Book and Twitter pages.

 

Rona Amiri is the Youth Ending Violence consultant at Battered Women’s Support Services.

She co-facilitates workshops for youth in the Greater Vancouver area. She is passionate about working with other youth and supporting them in their empowerment process. Her mission is to see a change in youth culture where young women and men feel empowered to interrupt sexist and abusive behaviors and help end gender violence.